[LMB] Elli, was Winterfair Gifts
Tzivia Adler
tadler at yeshivanet.com
Sun Dec 9 13:51:00 GMT 2007
> because it is exactly that quality that makes her one of the few people
> around who isn't consistently hypnotised by Miles, partly because it
> makes absolute sense to me that she should be that way, given her life
> to date and her goals, and I appreciate people with complex and
> understandable flaws, and partly because I suffer from the conviction
> that if she were a male character nobody would mind her behaviour in the
> least.
>
> Marna
>
>
(small note to the quote tixie - the above is one sentence, and can't see
where to snip!)
its interesting that you find Elli to be similar to a male character and
therefore not-to-be-criticized. I find her similar to a certain type of
male character too - the one-dimensional action hero, with no goal but
shoot-em-up and rise in the ranks. she has no firm connection to her family
at Kline station (that we hear of, it might take place off screen). I seem
to remember that her cousin on Kline station didn't recognize her, was that
long after her face-change? and wouldn't such a huge life-changing thing
like getting her face melted off be cause to write home - send pictures?
she seems to interact well with her subordinates and so perhaps she's just
like the career soldiers with no outside life I find so boring - and
annoying, when they run rough-shod over the civilians they come across.
ziviya
please pardon any bad writing here - i have three kids taking turns on the
mom-ladder
More information about the Lois-Bujold
mailing list