[LMB] LQ #37: IIlyan (Mon. Oct. 13th)
Michael R N Dolbear
little.egret at mrdolbear.freeserve.co.uk
Mon Oct 13 22:59:45 BST 2008
> From: Ed Burkhead <ed at edburkhead.com>
> To: 'Discussion of the works of Lois McMaster Bujold.'
<lois-bujold at lists.herald.co.uk>
> Subject: Re: [LMB] LQ #37: IIlyan (Mon. Oct. 13th)
> Date: 13 October 2008 21:08
> I think too many people assume that Illyan's "captain" rank was an
> army-equivalent of captain.
> There's text evidence that Barrayar uses some mix of these ranks in a
> I've never seen published. I don't think Lois has elucidated it enough
> figure it out. It may be that officers slip back and forth between
> depending on whether their current job is in the army or navy mode.
> *I* think that Negri's and Illyan's rank of captain was in the navy
> tradition. That puts his on-the-books rank at something just one step
Ooooooooooh ! Run away, it's the rank thread again !
Illyan was promoted from Lieutenant to Commander to Captain so he's navy
track with captain= (army) colonel.
Lois hath said that the back and forth depending on post held does happen.
See my and other's posts in the archives, search "Vice-admiral" should find
them all but note my suggestion that Aral's single military (army+navy) may
have removed some ranks so text evidence from Cordelia's Honor (SoH+B)
isn't evidence of the current rules, ie no lieutenant-commanders to be seen
in tVG or after but there are majors.
More information about the Lois-Bujold