[LMB] Ekaterin redux?
howard at brazee.net
Tue Oct 13 15:57:00 BST 2015
> On Oct 13, 2015, at 8:45 AM, Matthew George <matt.msg at gmail.com> wrote:
>> Amy "ruined" *Raiders of the Lost Arc* by pointing out the story would be
>> exactly the same if Indy had never been born.
> Miriam would have been tortured and killed. And while the Nazi base would
> presumably have been depopulated just the same, no one would have taken the
> Ark away until the rest of the Nazis came to find out what happened, and
> would then have a powerful mystic artifact under their control. (The
> burning away of the Nazi symbol from the crate is just self-indulgence on
> the part of Spielburg - OT Yahweh would have fit right in.)
> Heck, the movie starts with all of Indy's heroism coming to nothing. He's
> not the sort of hero who wins, he's the sort who survives.
I still like the observation above. To me, the big change is in the delightful post-ending under the credits. Indiana Jones got the ark to where it wanted to be.
More information about the Lois-Bujold