[LMB] Is Barr a rapist? or I'm misunderstanding beguilement?
almirantenaismith at gmail.com
Sun Aug 4 22:24:21 BST 2019
A problem with that is that Barr never really paid for his crime, (I think,
perhaps the voyage to the sea could be considered punishment? but not
I think that if Barr was in my life I would want him far away.
On Sat, Aug 3, 2019 at 10:15 AM M. Haller Yamada <thefabmadamem at yahoo.com>
> On Friday, August 2, 2019, 09:59:58 PM GMT+9, Howard Brazee <
> howard at brazee.net> wrote:
> > On Aug 2, 2019, at 5:23 AM, Federico Bergstein <
> almirantenaismith at gmail.com> wrote:
> > So, we can compare Barr's behavior to a guy spiking a girl's drink with
> > alcohol and then taking advantage of her lack of inhibitions.
> > Still pretty shitty, bordering on rapey.
> Good comparison.
> I think there isn't any denying that Barr used his powers for his own
> desires as a teenager, and yes, I think it was bordering on rapey -- or,
> crossed the line into rape. There's a difference between she probably would
> have said yes, and she did say yes.
> And this is a common discourse these days. But I will say, having read
> Lois all these years, I have to wonder if there's a place for redemption.
> Barr was a jerk and a rapist as a young man, but he reformed. AFAweK,
> he never used his powers to beguile anyone else into sex (or for
> other shady purposes). And this story is all about how he tried to make
> it right. It is not easy, and forgiveness is not always available.
> But I think Barr has been redeemed.
> Of course, if he ever did beguiled another Farmer, he'd be right back in
> condemned box -- and I don't know if I'd allow that he could redeem
> One bad period in life is one thing; repeated bad periods is . . . well,
> it would
> depend on who was harmed.
> Repeated falling-off-the-wagon without the problematic behaviors that often
> accompany it is redeemable. But assaulting a spouse while drunk, then
> getting clean, then falling off the wagon and assaulting a new spouse . . .
> that's a lot harder to make a case of redemption for. I'd like to say it
> possible, but it's such a gamble for the innocent bystanders to presume
> that a person will stay redeemed.
> To be honest, if Barr was in my life and I knew about all this, I don't
> if I would trust him. But I trust Lois to be fairly reliable, so in the
> story, I do
> trust him to stay reformed.
> It's a very, very complicated issue.
> Lois-Bujold mailing list message sent to almirantenaismith at gmail.com
> Lois-Bujold at lists.herald.co.uk
More information about the Lois-Bujold